How Should I Think?

The Workout You Didn't Sign Up For

Nobody chooses a hard season. But most of us are in one. Scripture doesn't tell us to rejoice because something bad happened — it tells us to rejoice because of what God is doing in us through it. That distinction changes everything.

7 min read

The Workout You Didn't Sign Up For
"Consider it pure joy, my brothers and sisters, whenever you face trials of many kinds, because you know that the testing of your faith produces perseverance." — James 1:2-3

Nobody chooses a hard season. But here you are.

That's what this is. A workout you didn't sign up for. And the question isn't whether you're in it — it's what you're going to do with it.

Maybe you're in one right now. Maybe you just crawled out of one and you're still catching your breath. Maybe you're watching someone you love go through something you can't fix, and all you can do is show up and pray it's enough.

I know that place. I've stood in it.

Not long ago I sent a text to my cousin. She'd lost her dad. She'd lost others too — it had been one of those years where grief doesn't wait for you to recover before it knocks again. I sat with my phone trying to figure out what to say to someone carrying that much. I didn't have anything clever. I didn't have an explanation. I just had what I believed.

So I said it.

"The scripture says to rejoice when you are going through challenges — but it's such a difficult thing to do that people get offended by the mere suggestion."

I told her about a friend of mine. A man I've known for years. A genuinely godly man — the kind who prays like he means it, who talks about God like he actually knows Him. In the span of one year, he lost his wife. His mother. His father.

One year.

And somewhere inside all that grief, something broke loose. He pulled away from everyone. He went quiet. He's still out there — I'm still praying for him — but the man I knew, the man who had God at the center of everything, went looking for somewhere to put all that pain and apparently couldn't find his way back.

I told my cousin: *Try to be grateful to God in spite of all of it. He loves you and is the source of everything good in your life.*

That's a hard thing to say to someone who is hurting. I know it. But I meant every word.

The Suggestion That Offends

There is almost no faster way to make a grieving person angry than to tell them to be grateful.

I understand that. When the loss is fresh and the weight is real, "count your blessings" sounds like someone handing you a paper umbrella in a flood. It doesn't help. It can actually make things worse, because now on top of everything you're grieving, you also feel guilty for not being grateful enough.

But I don't think that's what Scripture is actually asking of us.

James writes: *"Consider it pure joy, my brothers and sisters, whenever you face trials of many kinds, because you know that the testing of your faith produces perseverance. Let perseverance finish its work so that you may be mature and complete, not lacking anything."* (James 1:2-4)

Look at that word: *consider*. James is not commanding a feeling. He is not telling you to perform happiness over your pain. He is asking you to choose a perspective — to look at what is happening and decide to see past the immediate suffering to what it is producing. That is a mental act. A deliberate one. It is not easy. But it is not impossible.

Paul says the same thing differently: *"We also glory in our sufferings, because we know that suffering produces perseverance; perseverance, character; and character, hope."* (Romans 5:3-4)

Neither of them is telling you the pain isn't real. They are telling you the pain is not the whole story.

We are not called to rejoice *because* something terrible happened to us. We are called to rejoice *because of what God is doing in us through it*. The loss is still real. The grief is not wrong. But God is not standing outside the suffering waiting for it to be over — He is inside it with you, working, building something that could not have been built any other way. That is what we fix our eyes on. Not the wound. The One who redeems it.

The Boy Who Wouldn't Own It

I lead a small group of boys at Awana. A few weeks ago, one of them had a night that went completely sideways. He was hitting kids. Screaming. Completely out of control. He ended up suspended.

When I sat down with him afterward, he looked at me and said something I haven't been able to stop thinking about.

"It's not my fault. They were treating me wrong."

He probably wasn't entirely wrong about that. He may well have been mistreated. But his response to being mistreated had turned a hard situation into a worse one — for him, for the kids around him, and for his own standing in the group.

Here's the thing I told him. Here's the thing I want to tell you.

The hard stuff — the unfair stuff, the stuff that feels like it shouldn't be happening to you — it's not just something to survive. It is the workout. And nobody gets stronger without the workout.

God is doing something in you through this. The question is whether you'll cooperate with it or fight against it.

But then I found myself wondering: what if he doesn't? What if that boy never learns to respond differently? What if he keeps blaming, keeps retaliating, keeps refusing this particular growth? He stays exactly where he is. The anger stays. The isolation stays. The pattern repeats for years, maybe decades, and nothing changes.

That's not a neutral outcome. That's a harder story than the one he's already in.

And it's true for all of us. Every time we choose bitterness over gratitude, retaliation over patience, comfort over character — we stay stuck. The trial doesn't end. We just come out of it no different than we went in.

Here is what holds both of those things together at once: resisting growth has real consequences, and God pursues people even when they resist. Neither of those truths cancels the other out.

God's Warning About the Good Life

This is not a new problem. God saw it coming before His people ever set foot in the Promised Land.

Forty years they had wandered in the wilderness. Forty years of hard, of hungry, of depending on God for the next day's bread. And then the land — flowing with milk and honey, everything they had been waiting for — was finally within reach.

And God stopped them before they crossed over and said: be careful.

Not about the wilderness. About the comfort.

"When you have eaten and are satisfied, praise the Lord your God for the good land he has given you. Be careful that you do not forget the Lord your God… when your herds and flocks grow large and your silver and gold increase… then your heart will become proud and you will forget the Lord your God, who brought you out of Egypt, out of the land of slavery." (Deuteronomy 8:10-14)

Hard seasons have a way of keeping us honest. They remind us who we depend on. They strip away the illusion that we're managing just fine on our own.

Comfort is not the enemy of faith. But it is one of its most reliable distractions.

There is a phrase that has stayed with me for years: *do hard things*. It comes from a book by brothers Alex and Brett Harris. We don't want to do hard things. We want the milk and honey without the wilderness that preceded it. We want the character without the trials that build it.

But that's not how any of this works.

What You Build When You Choose to Look Up

My friend who fell away — I don't judge him. Not for a moment. Losing a spouse and both parents in a single year is a weight I don't know if I could carry either. I understand why something broke.

But I also know this: the Psalms are full of people who hit the floor. Psalm 22. Psalm 88. Voices crying from places so dark there was no light to see by. And God did not abandon them there. He met them there. Job lost everything — everything — and God was still present in the wreckage, even when Job couldn't feel it.

So if you have tried to be grateful and found yourself falling apart anyway — that is not the end of your story. God does not only show up for people who hold together. He goes looking for the ones who come apart. He is the father running down the road before the son even gets close to home.

Gratitude in suffering is not pretending. It is not denial. It is not a performance.

And it is worth saying plainly: God did not send your suffering to hurt you. James is clear about this one verse before he talks about trials — *"God cannot be tempted by evil, nor does he tempt anyone."* (James 1:13) God does not author the pain. But Romans 5 tells us He redeems it. He takes what is broken and builds something with it that could not have been built any other way.

There is a world of difference between a God who causes your suffering and a God who enters it with you.

Gratitude is the act of saying out loud: *I don't understand this. It hurts more than I have words for. And I still believe You are good. I still believe You are working. I still believe You have not left.*

That is faith under pressure. And faith under pressure is exactly what produces the perseverance Paul is talking about.

Your cousin holding on through grief — she is building something. That boy at Awana, the one who is slowly, imperfectly learning to respond to being mistreated without blowing everything up — he is building something. You, choosing to look up in the middle of a season that gives you every reason to look away — you are building something.

You may not be able to see it yet. But God is not finished. And He does not abandon what He starts.

One Question

If you're in a hard season right now, I'm not going to tell you it doesn't hurt. It does.

I'll just ask you this: Is it possible that what you're going through is not just happening *to* you — but is being used *for* you?

God loves you. He is the source of everything good in your life, including the strength you didn't know you had until this moment asked for it.

Thank Him anyway. Not because the pain isn't real. Because He is more real than the pain.

That's where the perseverance comes from. That's where the character comes from. That's where the hope comes from.

And hope, Paul says, does not disappoint.

"I am the way and the truth and the life." — John 14:6

What does that mean? Read: The Most Important Thing →